July 3, 2015 — American

Pastrami Sandwich

  • 20 mins
  • 1 PEOPLE
  • easy

‘…I don’t like mustard, but every once in a while, I think of Dad and America – and really enjoy a pastrami sarni .’

'Dad’s American influence…this is a classic sandwich which deserves respect…'

We'd love to see a photo when you plate up, please share #WhatDadCooked

Share this yummy recipe with a friend on WhatsApp

Follow us on Instagram — @WhatDadCooked

We'd love to see a photo when you plate up, please share #WhatDadCooked

Share this yummy recipe with a friend on WhatsApp

Follow us on Instagram — @WhatDadCooked

What you need

Lots of salt beef or pastrami (The type of salt beef and pastrami that Americans can buy is not available in UK stores. However, it is possible to buy thin slices of pre-packaged Pastrami – or slices cut from a joint at the deli counter.

Light rye bread, sourdough or any other type of bread.


Dill pickle

Mild cheese


Salt and pepper


Dad's Recipe Tales

Pastrami sandwich – a Jewish and American delicacy

Whilst on holiday visiting my sister, we went to a ‘Rubens’ in LA. I had a pastrami sandwich and chicken soup – it felt like I was making a pilgrimage. The sandwich arrived full of several ounces of pastrami piled onto rye with yellow mustard and pickle – perfect.

Jay Rayner tells about his relationship with the sandwich: in particular he has regular cravings which must be satisfied otherwise he starts going a bit gaga. Can you imagine someone who patronises three star restaurants for a living, yet is gastronomically dependent on an addiction to salt beef! I also suffer from these cravings. But finding somewhere to satisfy them has always been a challenge – until recently.

Corning beef (curing in brine) is an ancient Jewish tradition. This is why the sandwich is synonymous with Jewish New York delis – such as Rubens. The nearest I knew to such a deli was a very discrete Jewish café called the Nosh Bar in Windmill Street, Soho, opposite the Windmill revue theatre. It opened in 1944 – the food critic A.A. Gill, recalled how it was, ‘…staffed by ancient rude men with sad eyes and brilliantined hair…’

If I had a meeting in London I would plan my trips around the time when salt beef was being served (usually from noon until it finished a couple of hours later). Although I was looking forward to eating salt beef, the Nosh Bar itself was a rather intimidating place. The ‘ancient rude menwore full white catering coats and the walls were decorated with East End boxers. It was all a bit shifty, I felt like I was entering a run-down bar in the wrong part of town – where ordering required one to apprehensively approach a waiter and whisper in their ear: ‘I’m here for the salt beef…’

Of course, the salt beef was heaven. Sadly, The Nosh Bar closed in 2010. But these days, salt beef bars are widespread, Selfridges has one and new chains are cropping up such as Birley’s Bar and Tongue & Brisket. Even a local sandwich bar in Kingston-upon-Thames offers salt beef between certain hours of the day.

Salt beef and pastrami are similar – both are cured in a spiced brine – the salt beef is boiled, whereas the Pastrami is dried and given a spiced coating and lightly smoked before being cooked. Whichever meat you prefer pile it high between two slices of light rye and caraway, dress with plenty of mustard and garnish with dill pickle, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut are optional – enjoy.

How Dad Cooked It

Steam the pastrami or salt beef gently. Then build up the sandwich: butter the rye bread, spread mustard, slice dill pickle and pile on the hot Pastrami. A ‘Rubens’ has melted Swiss (mild) cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing (rather like ‘Thousand Island’ dressing).

Latest Recipes
Cassoulet de Toulouse à la Pappa

A perfect winter warmer – Cassoulet!

The Laughing Cow Lightest Loaded Quesadilla

Try Dad’s loaded low-fat salsa quesadillas with The Laughing Cow Lightest x8 cheese.

Melanzane Parmigiana with Dolmio 7 Vegetables Sun Ripened Tomato & Basil Pasta Sauce

An excellent way to turn a popular Italian slow food standard into an easy and quicker family classic.

© What Dad Cooked, 2024. Privacy Policy. Terms and Conditions. Twitter Instagram